Showing posts with label graphic novel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label graphic novel. Show all posts

Saturday, April 4, 2015

Safe Area Gorazde, by Joe Sacco


My cover looked cooler, but this is the best image I could find.

Genre: Graphic Novel, Memoir
Rating: ★★★★
Pages: 229
Published: 2007
Publisher: Jonathan Cape

This rating has a trigger warning for blood/gore imagery, war mentions, and the like.

Hello again, peaches! I'd apologize for the radio silence, but I'm really not that sorry about it. Study abroad has been pretty neat so far, and this past month I spent my Spring Break on (as one guy in my group put it) a "tour of the Ottoman Empire." 6 countries (Serbia, Bosnia, Croatia, Montenegro, Bulgaria, Turkey) in 10 days. My takeaway? The Balkans are beautiful and awesome and I wanna go back like nothing else. (As my friend, E., "I could make a life here!")

Because I'm me, and I was surrounded by enabling poli-sci majors, I found time during my trip to go to a few bookstores and picked up some """relevant reading.""" (Book haul post to come later. If I remember.) One of the books I got in Bosnia was Safe Area Gorazde ("Gorazde" pronounced like "gor-AJ-da"). I picked it up after visiting the Gallery 11/07/95, which is a permanent gallery about the Srebrenica massacre (or genocide, depending on who you're talking to). 

Real talk: the Gallery is super depressing and kind of awful, but in a good way? It was very informative and powerful, and definitely impacted my stay in Sarajevo. It was kind of surreal walking around the Balkans and examining the scars that the war left on both buildings and people. 

Building in Belgrade, Serbia.

Inside the Gallery
 
  
The building next to my hostel in Sarajevo.


(But this review is about Joe Sacco's time in Bosnia, not mine.)

Safe Area Gorazde details the time that journalist Joe Sacco spent in Gorazde, Bosnia, from 1994-1995. The book's material is largely based off of his interviews with Bosnian Muslims in the Muslim "enclave" of Gorazde, but also includes historical information and Sacco's opinion on the war. Safe Area Gorazde is meant as a memoir, but delivers Sacco's own brand of self-reflection and political observations. 

I was kinda familiar with Sacco's art before reading Safe Area Gorazde, and had some prior knowledge about the Balkan War. Gorazde was mentioned briefly in the Srebrenica exhibit as a UN Safe Area, but wasn't really elaborated on. My interest was piqued, then, when I saw Sacco's book in Sarajevo (it was one of the titles consistently available in English throughout the city) and I decided to purchase it. I didn't recall seeing Sacco's work in many stores previously, so I thought it would be a worthwhile buy. 

I enjoyed reading Safe Area Gorazde for its writing and art, and was appreciative of how Sacco established the book as his personal narrative during a portion of the conflict, as opposed to a definitive telling of the entire war. Sacco wrote about the privilege he enjoyed during the war (such as being able to travel relatively freely whereas people from Gorazde were stuck in the city). National privilege is an uncomfortable thing to admit when traveling, and I sometimes think that some writers, despite operating outside of the host society as foreigners, tend to over-identify with their subjects to the point where they believe they face the same challenges and restrictions as them.

Page from Safe Area Gorazde detailing the 1994 offensive. Copyright Joe Sacco.

Panels from Safe Area Gorazde. Copyright Joe Sacco.

I would absolutely recommend Safe Area Gorazde to anyone interested in learning about the Balkans War, the intersection of nationality and ethnicity, modern nation-building, and how international government organizations operate. It's a powerful book, a compelling memoir that Sacco shares with other individuals about a dark period in European/world history. Although dark and depressing, the story that Sacco tells does not stand for willful ignorance. 

Thursday, May 23, 2013

Are You My Mother?


I really, really, really wanted to read Are You My Mother? (by Alison Bechdel) immediately after finishing her "tragicomic" (and other memoir), Fun Home. I put it on hold at the library immediately after I finished, and began my anxiously wait for it to arrive. Although it was probably only like four or five days, it seemed like forever, and (as I mentioned in my last post) I went and picked up more books in the interim. (I was probably seen by the librarians as some weird college kid, who had nothing better to do than search the "Holds" shelf and walk around picking up and putting down books. I was really hoping that it had come in already, and they hadn't had the chance to email me about it.)

Are You My Mother? centers on Bechdel's complex relationship with her mother. It's longer than Fun Home, and is acknoledged by Bechdel to have begun long before her father's story. It's a long, complex narrative involving psychoanalysis, therapy, feminism, and sexuality. And really, that's just the beginning. This book was way harder for me to read than Fun Home - I was able to knock out Fun Home within a few hours, whereas with Mother took me multiple readings of working my way through it, carefully going over the dialogue, trying to digest ideas and theories that are way above me. Not to mention vocabulary that just... went by me. It was like a wind tunnel, and I was trying to grab at ideas in order to make Bechdel's story make sense.

Not to say that Bechdel didn't do a good job with this graphic novel; on the contrary, she composed a perfect companion piece to Fun Home. The fact that her mother is still living, and that their relationship is still unfolding, means that she does not have the luxury of having the years between her father's suicide and her writing the book to reflect and examine him. In any case, both books seem to have taken multiple years to complete. (Maybe a decade in total? I have no idea.)

It's kind of frustrating for me to admit that this book might be more advanced than me; often I found that I was comparing myself to Bechdel while I was reading the book. I compared what we're reading, writing, drawing, listening to... what we're aware of, quite simply. Whether or not she was the same age as me when I was making the comparison is of no consequence. The sad competition still remains; I acknowledge that Bechdel is superior, not only being older than me,  but also more worldly. She has obviously done more than her fair share of research in terms of psychology terms, and such. She mentions how (for a time), all she seemed to do was go to therapy, read about it, and write about it. Her experience serves her well; she knows her stuff, and is probably an expert in her own right.

(I've tried to get that last bit right, and hopefully it came off ok; I just really admire Bechdel, and I want that to come through in this not-quite-a-review.)

While I will probably try to read Mother again at some point in the future (when I feel more prepared, haha), I'm ready to return it to the library. I feel like this book is one where I need distance from it in order to cultivate my appreciation of it (ha!).

Since finishing, I've been researching Bechdel, and was surprised to find out that she is the person behind the Bechdel Test.

For those of you who don't know, the Bechdel Test is a series of criteria used to test gender bias in fiction (usually movies). To pass the test, the work must contain (1) two female characters who (2) talk to each other (3) about something other than a man.


As Sarkeesian states above, it isn't about whether or not a movie is feminist, but merely reveals gender biases in film. Although what this test reveals is a bit frustrating (here is a list of movies that do/don't pass the test*), I still think it's kind of cool that Bechdel is kind of the reason behind it. I'm kind of nerding out about this because I've only recently learned about the Bechdel test, so it's (for me) a way of connecting the "real world" and books. I guess having stuff like that, not-really "coincidences," is something that happens in the real world? Haha I need to get out more. 

(No, really)

Hopefully I will have another piece up before next Thursday, but we'll see! 

-M

*Although admittedly, this list is subjective to the viewer.